There are many mistakes in the Harry Potter series! The Sorcerer's Stone- Never read. The Chamber of Secrets- How can Tom Riddle go to Hogwarts 50 years ago? Since Bellatrix Lestrange was cousin to Sirius Black, and younger sister of Narcissa Malfoy, who was in Black's year and also Riddle's... The Prisoner of Akzaban- The Goblet of Fire- Never read. The Order of the Phoenix- Snape taught for 16 years? He is only 25, so 25-16=9. ... Show more
There are many mistakes in the Harry Potter series! The Sorcerer's Stone- Never read. The Chamber of Secrets- How can Tom Riddle go to Hogwarts 50 years ago? Since Bellatrix Lestrange was cousin to Sirius Black, and younger sister of Narcissa Malfoy, who was in Black's year and also Riddle's... The Prisoner of Akzaban- The Goblet of Fire- Never read. The Order of the Phoenix- Snape taught for 16 years? He is only 25, so 25-16=9. He cannot teach at nine- he's not even at Hogwarts yet! The Half-Blood Prince- Lupin is not old- he's only 26 or 27. The Deathly Hallows- Never read. Did you find more? Please write them in this thread!
Yeah Tonks is daughter of Andromeda, who is Bellatrix's sister and Sirius' cousin. So, she is a second cousin. And if you think that Snape is 25 years old in HP & the Order of the Phoenix, when Harry is 15, then do you think Lily and James gave birth to Harry at an age of... Show more
Yeah Tonks is daughter of Andromeda, who is Bellatrix's sister and Sirius' cousin. So, she is a second cousin. And if you think that Snape is 25 years old in HP & the Order of the Phoenix, when Harry is 15, then do you think Lily and James gave birth to Harry at an age of 25-15=10?? They didn't even go to Hogwarts then!! Lupin, Snape, Sirius, Lily and James are all the same age, that is nearly THIRTY SIX! Bellatrix was NEVER in Tom Riddle's year. She became a death eater in her teenage, so did Snape. And at that time, VOLDEMORT existed. That's why no one KNEW he was the same Tom Riddle. Tom Riddle was at Hogwarts with Myrtle and Hagrid! Lucius was in seventh year when James, Snape etc. joined Hogwarts, so was Narcissa, and again . . . there was NO Tom Riddle there! Get your facts right before you point out someone's errors!!
Which series is your favorite? See the latest message!
By:
happyloser
All of them are all very good. I can't decide. I MIGHT prefer the Percy Jackson series over heroes of Olympus and maybe the Harry Potter series as well, but I don't know about the Believing Magic Series. I vote for all! And I'm the only person allowed to- I wrote the message! ;-)
Tonks is not Sirius's cousin.
Yeah Tonks is daughter of Andromeda, who is Bellatrix's sister and Sirius' cousin. So, she is a second cousin. And if you think that Snape is 25 years old in HP & the Order of the Phoenix, when Harry is 15, then do you think Lily and James gave birth to Harry at an age of... Show more
Yeah Tonks is daughter of Andromeda, who is Bellatrix's sister and Sirius' cousin. So, she is a second cousin. And if you think that Snape is 25 years old in HP & the Order of the Phoenix, when Harry is 15, then do you think Lily and James gave birth to Harry at an age of 25-15=10?? They didn't even go to Hogwarts then!!
Lupin, Snape, Sirius, Lily and James are all the same age, that is nearly THIRTY SIX! Bellatrix was NEVER in Tom Riddle's year. She became a death eater in her teenage, so did Snape. And at that time, VOLDEMORT existed. That's why no one KNEW he was the same Tom Riddle. Tom Riddle was at Hogwarts with Myrtle and Hagrid! Lucius was in seventh year when James, Snape etc. joined Hogwarts, so was Narcissa, and again . . . there was NO Tom Riddle there!
Get your facts right before you point out someone's errors!!